CC By(e Bye)

(Reader Attention Conservation Warning…This is a self-indulgent post, written as a diary entry as much as anything else…  If you want to know what Creative Commons is, you can read this.) Tomorrow I finish my year’s term as Creative Commons Board Chair and step down from the board… I am succeeded as Chair by Esther Wojcicki who is going to be  fabulous.  Her work as an award winning teacher and a journalist and her focus on making technology work for education are exactly what we need as an organization.

I have been a member of the board from the beginning.  My e-mail folders have correspondence dating from 2001 when we thought it would be called “The IP Conservancy”  (hardly a name to inspire excitement) and that it would sit on our computers and hold great works donated by public spirited authors and heirs, as well as a free-for-all potlatch donated by the community.

Little by little those ideas (and that name) disappeared, and the Creative Commons you know now appeared.  The same e-mail history tells the story of the continual push to have a CC for Science — eventually founded by me, Hal Abelson and Eric Saltzman in 2004 — and to move CC more centrally into education.  (I was one of the co-founders of ccLearn in 2007).  At the beginning we dreamed, ambitiously, of having 10,000 digital artifacts under CC licenses.  There are now more than 200 million.   Through the process I got to work with astounding people.  Larry Lessig, first of all, who is the true moving force behind CC.  Larry invited me onto the board before there was an “it” to be on the board of, and is one of my dearest friends.  Molly van Houweling, who was CC’s first leader, Glenn Brown, Diane Cabell, John Wilbanks, Mike Linksvayer,  Ben Adida, Aaron Swartz, Mia Garlick… the list goes on and on; it would be Oscar-night long if I mentioned everyone — each one of them someone who at a particular moment did something without which the CC that exists now would not.

Then there is the CC board, with whom I shared fears, beers, triumphs, late night grant writing sessions,  and laughs too many to count. Working with Mike Carroll, Hal Abelson and Eric Saltzman was a particular delight.  [Vivid snapshots: Hal Abelson, one of the greatest computer scientists of his generation, proofreading the first CC website, line by line and link by link, like a high school intern. Laurie Racine, who heard a half-baked, back of the envelope pitch, and started the flow of money to make it happen.  Mike Carroll frowning as he worked on the first draft of the first CC license — our Jefferson. [;->] Glenn Brown smiling with relief as everyone (finally) started to dance at the David Byrne/Gilberto Gil concert.  The first time I got yelled at by a collecting society rep. The first time we were mischaracterized in the press.  The first sleepless night thinking about the budget.Being condemned because the licenses allowed too much choice.. and too little. (All experiences that were to be repeated.) The first grant I co-wrote that was funded.  The 20th grant I co-wrote that wasn’t.  Seeing MIT Open Courseware come out — and realizing with a gulp that we had provided a key part of the architecture for global open learning. The first time someone said “lets put this under a CC license” and everyone in the room nodded, not knowing I had any connection to the organization. One of the founders of Google, saying to me, without apparent irony, “well, you have such a strong brand…” People from 40 countries at an iCommons event —  brilliant, accomplished people who were lawyers, academics, artists, judges — talking about CC as if it had always been there. Having a stranger explain CC to me. Michelle Thorne asking me about careers in open content.. I nearly chuckled, but she had the last laugh, she found one! The first time a collecting society rep suggested we could work together. The time a Nobel prize winner said “why doesn’t CC do something about this?” as if that were the most natural question in the world.]

And it meant I got to have friends around the world who put something of themselves into CC and changed it for the better — Joi Ito, our CEO, Paul Keller, Alek Tarkowski, Fred Benenson, Prodromos Tsiavos, Melanie dulong DeRosnay, Andrés Guadamuz, Tomislav Medak, Bernt Hugenholtz, Brian Fitzgerald, the whole of the CCi network…   I could just go on mentioning names but I’d be doing it more to spur my own memories than to communicate — still that is a function of blogs too.  Anyway, this unseemly display of nostalgia and the rehearsal of so many friends’ names serves only to say how very proud I am to have been a part of CC and how excited I am for its future.  We will be a central part of the movement that changes the way science is done, I think — the current inefficiencies are too great and the potential gain too enormous to let the chance slide.  I think open education is an idea which makes too much sense to be resisted (which is not to say it won’t be.)  And the idea of building a global creative commons is just as inspiring as its always been.

Still, its been a long time and after that many years, anyone deserves a bit of a rest and a change.  With the creation of Science Commons and ccLearn, and the transition from Larry’s leadership over, I feel as if I’ve already accomplished a lot of what I can contribute.  I am not going away of course.  I will continue to be a strong supporter of CC and particularly of Science Commons — it needs your help, give now!  I going to be doing much more work with the organization I set up at Duke, the Center for the Study of the Public Domain, including finishing a comic book on the history of music and working with the Center for Public Genomics.  I will be serving as a board member on the Public Library of Science — believing that there are lots of options for collaboration down the line.  And I will be looking on with interest,  awe (and occasional total, flummoxed confusion — remember, its Creative Commons we are talking about here!) to see what the future brings.  Keep in touch.  I will.

Tuesday, March 31st, 2009 Creative Commons, science, Science Commons

5 Comments to CC By(e Bye)

  1. […] see outgoing chair James Boyle’s CC BY(e bye) post — finely crafted writing down to the title, as we have come to expect. As you’ll […]

  2. Esther Wojcicki, new CC board chair - Creative Commons on April 1st, 2009
  3. Thanks for the community conference call, Jamie. I will always be a fan of your “Would we have to forbid Christmas?” trope.

    All the best,

  4. Thom Hastings on April 2nd, 2009
  5. […] this blog post — by outgoing Creative Commons Board Chair, one of CC’s founder and other CC […]

  6. Creative Commons and what it means to be human « World Guide on April 5th, 2009
  7. […] read outgoing chair James Boyle’s CC BY(e bye) post where he discusses some of the history of the movement and explains how he will remain […]

  8. Esther Wojcicki, CC’s new board chair | Kuba Seniorita Blog and links on April 5th, 2009
  9. […] read outgoing chair James Boyle’s CC BY(e bye) post where he discusses some of the history of the movement and explains how he will remain […]

  10. » Esther Wojcicki, CC’s new board chair on April 22nd, 2009

From the Blog

  • The Line: AI & The Future Of Personhood

    James Boyle

    My new book, The Line: AI and the Future of Personhood, will be published by MIT Press in 2024 under a Creative Commons License and MIT is allowing me to post preprint excerpts. The book is a labor of (mainly) love — together with the familiar accompanying authorial side-dishes: excited discovery, frustration, writing block, self-loathing, epiphany, and massive societal change that means you have to rewrite everything. So just the usual stuff. It is not a run-of-the-mill academic discussion, though. For one thing, I hope it is readable. It might even occasionally make you laugh. For another, I will spend as much time on art and constitutional law as I do on ethics, treat movies and books and the heated debates about corporate personality as seriously as I do the abstract philosophy of personhood. These are the cultural materials with which we will build our new conceptions of personhood, elaborate our fears and our empathy, stress our commonalities and our differences. To download the first two chapters, click here. For a sample, read on…..

    read more
  • Everything You Know About §230 Is Wrong (But Why?)

    James Boyle, Oct 25th, 2021

    There are a few useful phrases that allow one instantly to classify a statement.  For example, if any piece of popular health advice contains the word “toxins,” you can probably disregard it.  Other than, “avoid ingesting them.” Another such heuristic is that if someone tells you “I just read something about §230..” the smart bet is to respond, “you were probably misinformed.” 

    read more

  • Free, Open, Intellectual Property Textbook

    Jennifer Jenkins and I have just published the 2021 edition of our free, Creative Commons licensed, Intellectual Property textbook.

    read more

  • ‘Dumping: On Law Reviews’. The Green Bag

    I will probably never be published in a law review ever again after writing this.  I find myself curiously untroubled by the thought.  

    read more

  • Mark of the Devil: The University as Brand Bully

    I teach at Duke University, an institution I love.  The reverse may not be true however, at least after my most recent paper (with Jennifer Jenkins) — Mark of the Devil:  The University as Brand Bully.  (forthcoming in the Fordham Intellectual Property and Entertainment Law Journal).  The paper is about the university most frequently accused of being a “trademark bully” — an entity that makes assertions and threats far beyond what trademark law actually allows, something that is all too common, with costs to both competition and free speech.   Unfortunately, that university is our own — Duke. 

    read more

  • Tragedy/Comedy of the Commons @ 50

    The Economist was kind enough to ask me to write an article commemorating the 50th anniversary of Garrett Hardin’s Tragedy of the Commons.  ““THE ONLY way we can preserve and nurture other and more precious freedoms is by relinquishing the freedom to breed.” This ominous sentence comes not from China’s one-child policy but from one of the 20th century’s most influential—and misunderstood—essays in economics. “The tragedy of the commons”, by Garrett Hardin, marks its 50th anniversary on December 13th.”  Read the rest here.

  • Theft: A History of Music — Free Comic


    read more

  • (When) Is Copyright Reform Possible?

    I am posting here a draft of a chapter for Ruth Okediji’s forthcoming book on the possibilities of international intellectual property reform.  In my case, the article recounts the lessons I learned from being part of the Hargreaves Review of Intellectual Property in the UK.

    “In the five months we have had to compile the Review, we have sought never to lose sight of David Cameron’s “exam question”. Could it be true that laws designed more than three centuries ago with the express purpose of creating economic incentives for innovation by protecting creators’ rights are today obstructing innovation and economic growth? The short answer is: yes. We have found that the UK’s intellectual property framework, especially with regard to copyright, is falling behind what is needed. Copyright, once the exclusive concern of authors and their publishers, is today preventing medical researchers studying data and text in pursuit of new treatments. Copying has become basic to numerous industrial processes, as well as to a burgeoning service economy based upon the internet. The UK cannot afford to let a legal framework designed around artists impede vigorous participation in these emerging business sectors.” Ian Hargreaves, Foreword: Hargreaves Review (2011)

    Read the chapter.

  • Apple Updates — A Comic

    sampleEver been utterly frustrated, made furious, by an Apple upgrade that made things worse?  This post is for you.  (With apologies to Randall Munroe.)

    read more

  • Open Coursebook in Intellectual Property

    Cover of Intellectual Property: Law & the Information Society and link to purchase at Amazon.comDuke’s Center for the Study of the Public Domain is announcing the publication of Intellectual Property: Law & the Information Society—Cases and Materials by James Boyle and Jennifer Jenkins. This book, the first in a series of Duke Open Coursebooks, is available for free download under a Creative Commons license. If you do not want to use the entire casebook you can view and download the individual chapters (in a variety of formats) here. It can also be purchased in a glossy paperback print edition for $29.99, $130 cheaper than other intellectual property casebooks.

    read more

  • So you’ve invented fantasy football, now what?

    We are posting excerpts from our new coursebook Intellectual Property: Law and the Information Society which will be published in two weeks is out now! It will be is of course  freely downloadable, and sold in paper for about $135 less than other casebooks.  (And yes, it will include  discussions  of whether one should ever use the term “intellectual property.” )  The book is full of practice examples..  This is one from Chapter One, on the theories behind intellectual property: “What if you came up with the idea of Fantasy Football?”  No legal knowledge necessary.  Why don’t you test your argumentative abilities…?

    read more

  • Free/Low Cost Intellectual Property Statutory Supplement

    Today, we are proud to announce the publication of our 2014 Intellectual Property  Statutory Supplement as a freely downloadable Open Course Book. Statutes Cover  It offers the full text of the Federal Trademark, Copyright and Patent statutes (including edits detailing the changes made by the America Invents Act.)  It also has a number of important international treaties and a  chart which compares the various types of Federal intellectual property rights — their constitutional basis, subject matter, length, exceptions and so on.You can see it here in print, or download it for free, here

    read more

  • Persnickety Snit

    This is the fourth in a series of postings of material drawn from our forthcoming, Creative Commons licensed, open coursebook on Intellectual Property.  It is about lawyers and language. 

    read more

  • Macaulay on Copyright

    Macaulay’s 1841 speech to the House of Commons on copyright law is often cited and not much read.  In fact, the phrase “cite unseen” gains a new meaning.  That is a shame, because it is masterful.  (And funny.) One fascinating moment?  When Macaulay warns that copyright maximalism will lead to a future of rampant illegality, as all happily violate a law that is presumed to have lost all moral legitimacy.

    At present the holder of copyright has the public feeling on his side. Those who invade copyright are regarded as knaves who take the bread out of the mouths of deserving men. Everybody is well pleased to see them restrained by the law, and compelled to refund their ill-gotten gains. No tradesman of good repute will have anything to do with such disgraceful transactions. Pass this law: and that feeling is at an end. Men very different from the present race of piratical booksellers will soon infringe this intolerable monopoly. Great masses of capital will be constantly employed in the violation of the law. Every art will be employed to evade legal pursuit; and the whole nation will be in the plot…  Remember too that, when once it ceases to be considered as wrong and discreditable to invade literary property, no person can say where the invasion will stop. The public seldom makes nice distinctions. The wholesome copyright which now exists will share in the disgrace and danger of the new copyright which you are about to create.

    The legal change he thought would do that?  Extending copyright to the absurd length of life plus 50 years.  (It is now life plus 70).  Ah, Thomas, if only you could have been there for the Sonny Bono Term Extension debates.

    read more

  • Mark Twain on the Need for Perpetual Copyright

    This is the second in a series of postings of material drawn from our forthcoming, Creative Commons licensed, open coursebook on Intellectual Property.  The first was Victor Hugo: Guardian of the Public Domain The book will be released in late August.

    In 1906, Samuel Clemens (who we remember better by his pen name Mark Twain) addressed Congress on the reform of the Copyright Act.  Delicious.

    read more

  • Victor Hugo: Guardian of the Public Domain

    Jennifer Jenkins and I are frantically working to put together a new open casebook on Intellectual Property Law.  (It will be available, in beta version, this Fall under a CC license, and freely downloadable in multiple formats of course.  Plus it should sell in paper form for about $130 less than the competing casebooks. The accompanying statutory supplement will be 1/5  the price of most statutory supplements — also freely downloadable.)  More about that later.  While assembling the materials for a casebook, one gets to revisit the archives, reread the great writers.  Today I was revisiting Victor Hugo.  Hugo was a fabulous — inspiring, passionate — proponent of the rights of authors, and the connection of those rights to free expression and free ideas.

    read more

  • “We Need To Start Seeing Other Futures..”

    Today is the second day of “Copyright Week!” Talk about a lede. That sentence has all the inherent excitement of “Periodontal Health Awareness Week” or “‘Hug Your Proctologist! No, After He’s Washed His Hands’ Week.” And that’s a shame. Copyright Week is a week devoted to our relationship with our own culture. Hint: things aren’t going well. The relationship is on the rocks.

    read more

  • Discussion: “The Foolish War Against Song-Lyric Websites”

    Professor Alex Sayf Cummings, author of a fascinating book called Democracy of Sound: Music Piracy and the Remaking of American Copyright in the 20th Century (recommended as a  thought-provoking read)  has an interesting  post up about attempts to shut down music lyric sites such as

    read more

  • The Top Ten List of a Conference Planner

    Academics (and others) arrange conferences.  Perfectly normal people are invited to those conferences to speak.  Most of them are just as charming as can be… but then there are the special ones.  This Top 10 List of the special people one has to respond to is devoted to all conference planners everywhere.  Hold your heads up high.  After this, purgatory should be a snap.

    read more

  • (EM)I Has A Dream

    EM(I) Has A DreamAugust 28th, 2013 is the 50th anniversary of Martin Luther King’s “I Have a Dream” speech. The copyright in the speech is administered by EMI, with the consent of the King family. Thus the speech may not be freely played on video or reproduced and costlessly distributed across the nation — even today. Its transient appearance depends on the copyright owner’s momentary sufferance, not public right. It may disappear from your video library tomorrow. It has even been licensed to advertise commercial products, including cars and mobile phone plans.

    read more

  • The Prosecution of Aaron: A Response to Orin Kerr

    Aaron Swartz committed suicide last week.  He was 26, a genius and my friend.  Not a really good friend, but someone I had worked with off and on for 11 years, liked a lot, had laughed with frequently, occasionally shaken my head over and deeply admired.

    read more

  • The Hargreaves Review

    An Intellectual Property System for the Internet Age

    James Boyle

    In November 2010, the Prime Minister commissioned a review of the Britain’s intellectual property laws and their effect on economic growth, quoting the founders of Google that “they could never have started their company in Britain” because of a lack of flexibility in British copyright..  Mr. Cameron wanted to see if we could have UK intellectual property laws “fit for the Internet age.”   Today the Review will be published. Its conclusion?  “Could it be true that laws designed more than three centuries ago with the express purpose of creating economic incentives for innovation by protecting creators’ rights are today obstructing innovation and economic growth?  The short answer is: yes.” Those words are from Professor Ian Hargreaves, head of the Review.   (Full disclosure: I was on the Review’s panel of expert advisors.)

    read more

  • Keith Aoki — A Remembrance Book

    A slideshow and downloadable book remembering Keith in words and pictures.  You can order a glossy, high quality copy of the book itself here from Createspace or here from Amazon.  We tried to make it as beautiful as something Keith would create.  We failed. But we came close; have a look at how striking it is… all because of Keith’s art.

    read more

  • Now THAT is how you teach a class

    read more

  • RIP, Keith Aoki

    Our friend, colleague, co-author and brilliant artist and scholar Keith Aoki died yesterday in his house in Sacramento.  He was 55 years old.

    read more

  • Follow thepublicdomain on Twitter.